Man Utd’s Midfield Dilemma: Hjulmand or Baleba Transfer?

Manchester United is finally turning their attention to midfield after heavily investing in their forward line. The Red Devils have already splashed over £200 million on attackers Benjamin Sesko, Bryan Mbeumo, and Matheus Cunha, following a forgettable 2024/25 campaign. After finishing 15th in the Premier League and watching Tottenham lift the Europa League trophy at their expense, United is now focused on giving new manager Rubem Amorim the midfield reinforcements he needs.

Transfer Targets: Hjulmand and Baleba

Two names are dominating the transfer gossip columns: Sporting CP’s Morten Hjulmand and Brighton’s Carlos Baleba.

  • Morten Hjulmand: Has history with Amorim, having won two Primeira Liga titles under his management in Lisbon. Crucially, he might cost less than half the price of Baleba, offering a more budget-friendly option.
  • Carlos Baleba: Brighton is demanding north of £100 million for this Cameroonian midfielder. Despite his hefty price tag, Baleba stands out due to his youth and proven Premier League experience.

Who Fits Best?

Baleba: The Long-Term Investment

Baleba could be the smarter long-term investment, given he is five years younger than Hjulmand. If United can negotiate the eye-watering asking price down, Baleba offers significant promise.

  • Offensive Output: Last season, Baleba scored three league goals and created three big chances, compared to Hjulmand’s two goals and two big chances.
  • Defensive Prowess: Baleba’s Premier League stats are impressive:
  • Tackles: 2.3 per 90 minutes vs. Hjulmand’s 1.9
  • Interceptions: 1.4 vs. 1.0
  • Clearances: 1.3 vs. 1.1
  • Blocked shots: 0.5 vs. 0.1

Hjulmand: A Strategic Choice

If negotiating Baleba’s fee proves impossible, Hjulmand is a sensible alternative, particularly given his understanding of Amorim’s tactical approach.

  • Experience: Hjulmand is familiar with Amorim’s system, which could be invaluable in implementing the manager’s strategies efficiently.
  • Defensive Attribute: Hjulmand is dribbled past less frequently compared to Baleba (0.7 times per 90 minutes versus 0.9).

Conclusion

Baleba represents a dynamic option for United, offering long-term value if his transfer fee can be reduced. However, Hjulmand is not far behind, especially with his existing rapport with Amorim, providing a more cost-effective and strategic acquisition. Whether it’s Baleba’s Premier League dynamism or Hjulmand’s tactical familiarity, United must weigh their options carefully to strengthen their midfield effectively.

Scroll to Top